UX (user experience) as a discipline is messy, imperfect, filled with overlapping methodologies. It's an umbrella term that's
so broad it can feel meaningless. It sometimes lacks internal consistency. It's a work in progress. It's immature and
it needs to get better.
But...
This isn't an exuse to dismiss UX
All of the javascript
Why should I care about UX?
Your ability to practice introspection and empathy and then use your learning in each to develop the other, in other words,
your ability to practice inpathy, shifts your mindset around how you interact with others.
Why can it be so hard to talk to designers about design?
Let's apply some user empathy
feedback without context
back seat designing
git-blame or competetive work cultures
focus on aesthetics or trends over strategy
If developers got feedback like designers...
Hey! I know this isn't a PR yet, but why did you pick that class name...?
Hey - FYI I think I saw that library in use at company XX the other day. Don't want to copy code, hey!
I'm not a programmer, but, that function looks awfully complex... Shouldn't it be simpler!?
So how do we do it better?
Focus on...
Getting the context
The intended audience
Design strategy
For example
I had some responses to your design, but I'm not sure I have all the most recent context. Could you give
me a quick update before I offer any feedback?
For example
I'm concerned this design will be hard to use for our target audience because the added complexity increases
cognitive load...
For example
Can we chat about hierarchy of information on this view? I think the visual prominence given to XX
is unnecessary given our strategy of getting users to focus on YY.
Aesthetic preference -vs- Design strategy
We try not to get them mixed up
Activity time!
Let's practice some design critique
Given a door handle...
Which choice do you think is more strategic (less about personal tastes)?
A) Users may not see it on a black door
B) It just doesn't 'pop' enough
Given a checkout flow...
Which choice do you think is more strategic?
A) I don't like this shade of turquoise
B) I'm not sure which is the primary button
Given this hospital software...
Which feedback do you think is more strategic?
A) It's too much information to process
B) It looks old skool
Activity time!
Let's practice some UX design
The problem
Eric is trying to save money on household costs.
Research learnings
He thinks he could probably spend less on food and cleaning supplies he buys regularly
Doesn't want to compromise on ethics or quality
He is time poor
Doesn't enjoy shopping around
He'd love to save time
Bullet points & notes
1 minute
Sketch your first idea
2 minutes
Crazy 8s (mini)
Share & compare
2 minutes
meta-solutions
The space of possible solutions to any given user problem is infinite